Dad dot info
DAD.info form. Ask questions, get answers

Judge rules for baby vaccination to avoid meningitis despite mother’s opposition

A baby should be vaccinated against infections which can lead to meningitis despite his mother’s opposition, a High Court judge has ruled

 

The seven-month-old boy’s mother said the Haemophilus Influenza Type b (Hib) vaccine and the pneumococcal conjugate (PCV) vaccine could cause adverse reactions.

But social services staff said vaccination was in the youngster’s best interests – and Mr Justice MacDonald agreed.

The judge has delivered a ruling after analysing competing arguments at a hearing in the Family Division of the High Court in London.

He said the little boy could not be identified.

Bosses at Barnet Council in London had asked for permission to arrange for the youngster to be vaccinated.

Mr Justice MacDonald said evidence showed that Haemophilus influenza Type b was a serious bacterial infection which usually attacked children under five.

He said that before the introduction of the Hib vaccine, the Hib infection was the leading cause of bacterial meningitis.

Pneumococcal disease comprised a range of bacterial infections, said the judge.

Evidence showed that children under two were particularly vulnerable and germs could cause pneumonia, septicaemia and meningitis.

The woman said she had older children who had needed hospital treatment after suffering adverse reactions.

But social services bosses said the consequences of not vaccinating could be grave.

They said medical evidence showed that vaccination was plainly in the little boy’s best interests.

Mr Justice MacDonald ruled against the mother.

“Whilst the mother submits that risk of infection is low, and whilst the expert evidence supports that contention to a certain extent, it is plain on the evidence before the court that the consequences of that risk becoming manifest are grave indeed, with the meningitis in particular being a rapidly progressive infection, hard to diagnose and treat in time to prevent permanent damage or even death,” he said.

“I am satisfied that it is appropriate in this case to make a declaration under the inherent jurisdiction of the High Court that it is in (the baby’s) best interests for the local authority to be given permission to arrange for him to receive the Hib vaccine and the PCV vaccine.”

The judge said he was not making a decision on whether immunisation was “a good thing or bad thing generally”.

He added: “I emphasise that the court is not saying anything about the merits of vaccination more widely and does not in any way seek to dictate how this issue should be approached in other situations.

“This judgment is concerned solely with an evaluation of one child’s best interests based on the very particular circumstances of this case.”

Related entries

Your Guide to the European Championships

Your Guide to the European Championships

Like it or loathe it, the next few weeks are going to be all about football. If you want the basics to keep up with your footy crazy kids we’ve compiled this handy guide to give you an overview of the upcoming European Championships. UEFA.com What are the European...

The Duke and Duchess of Sussex welcome a new baby girl

The Duke and Duchess of Sussex welcome a new baby girl

Welcome to the world Baby Lilibet. The Dad.info team loves a baby and the new daughter of the Duke and Duchess of Sussex is just the good news we need. https://twitter.com/RoyalFamily/status/1401614927236841474 Named for her grandmother and great-grandmother, Lilibet...

Latest entries

The Best Family Walks in Britain

The Best Family Walks in Britain

We could all do with exercise, fresh air and some lovely low-cost days out, not to mention some beautiful scenery. Charles Clinkard have put together a list of the 40 greatest walks for families in Britain, taking into account a number of helpful amenities such as...

How To Keep Your Child Safe Online

How To Keep Your Child Safe Online

As a parent of a 10 year old who is rapidly approaching the age where he will be getting his own phone, I’m concerned about ensuring he isn’t exposed to a cavalcade of disturbing things online. I’m worrying about bullying, about him being contacted or making friends...

21 Things You Didn’t Know About Japan

21 Things You Didn’t Know About Japan

The Olympics have started! Despite a lack of fans (crowd noise will be piped into the stadiums instead) the event is still as important as ever and makes for great summer viewing. So at Dad.Info we have rounded up 21 interesting facts about Japan to both liberally...

Pin It on Pinterest